The Problem with 'They Should Just Speak English': A Call for Linguistic Inclusion in Education
Language is more than just a tool for communication; it's an integral part of our identities and cultures. Yet, in diverse educational settings, we often hear the phrase "they should just speak English" – a statement that overlooks the richness and benefits of linguistic diversity. This statement, while seemingly innocuous, carries with it a multitude of problematic implications. This blog post aims to delve into why such a mindset can be damaging in an educational context and how educators can foster a more inclusive, language-friendly environment in their classrooms.
The Problem
The phrase "they should just speak English" is a sentiment that belies an unfortunate disregard for linguistic diversity. This mindset not only marginalizes the wealth of languages our students bring into the classroom, but it also underestimates the importance of multilingualism in a rapidly globalizing world (García, 2009).
First and foremost, such a statement fails to acknowledge the broad spectrum of languages that exist, each with its unique syntax, semantics, and cultural nuances. By suggesting that English should be the only language spoken, other languages are sidelined, and the cultural richness they carry is dismissed (Cummins, 2000).
Secondly, this perspective overlooks the cognitive, social, and emotional benefits associated with bilingualism and multilingualism. Numerous studies have shown that bilingualism can enhance cognitive flexibility, improve problem-solving abilities, and foster cultural sensitivity (Bialystok, 2001). By advocating for monolingual English communication, we risk depriving students of these advantageous skills. Moreover, the insistence on speaking only English can create an unwelcoming and exclusionary environment for non-native English speakers. It can cause feelings of marginalization and alienation, potentially impacting their sense of belonging, self-esteem, and academic engagement (Valdés, 2001).
Finally, it's important to remember that language is closely tied to identity (Norton, 2013). When we devalue a student's native language, we may inadvertently devalue a part of their identity.
In summary, the lack of recognition and value for linguistic diversity is not just a matter of language equity; it's a matter of cultural respect, cognitive development, and educational inclusivity (Gay, 2010). As educators, it's imperative to cultivate an environment that celebrates, rather than suppresses, linguistic diversity.
What Educators Can Do
Educators have a crucial role to play in fostering linguistic diversity and inclusivity. They can take proactive measures to respect all languages, create inclusive, language-friendly classrooms, and support English learners while also valuing their native languages.
Respecting and Valuing All Languages
Educators should strive to recognize and appreciate the variety of languages that students bring to the classroom. This could involve learning to greet in different languages, incorporating multicultural literature into the curriculum (Banks & Banks, 2004), or encouraging students to share phrases from their native language during class discussions (Lucas & Villegas, 2011).
Creating Inclusive, Language-Friendly Classrooms
An inclusive, language-friendly classroom is one where all languages are welcome. Here are several strategies for achieving this:
Multilingual Resources: Providing learning resources in multiple languages can support non-native English speakers and expose English-speaking students to other languages (García & Sylvan, 2011).
Collaborative Learning: Encouraging collaborative learning activities where students can leverage their linguistic strengths promotes peer learning and fosters community (Johnson & Johnson, 2009).
Cultural Celebrations: Celebrating linguistic and cultural diversity through events like International Mother Language Day lets students share their traditions, foods, music, and stories (Nieto, 2010).
Supporting English Learners While Valuing Their Native Languages
Supporting English learners doesn't mean disregarding their native languages. Here's how to strike the balance:
Translanguaging: Encourage translanguaging, which involves leveraging students' full linguistic repertoire for learning. It allows students to use their native language(s) to understand new concepts (García & Leiva, 2014).
Dual Language Programs: Consider implementing dual language programs, which aim to develop proficiency in two languages. These programs value and promote bilingualism and biliteracy (Thomas & Collier, 2002).
Parental Engagement: Engage with parents in their native language whenever possible. This shows respect for their language and culture and helps build strong school-home connections (Epstein, 2018).
September is Hispanic Heritage Month. Click here for a resource to help you celebrate the contributions of Latino leaders.
So the next time someone says, “This is America. They should just speak English,” say this
I’m hearing some fear there. Can you tell me where that stems from?
Where does that belief you hold come from?
What is the worst case scenario? What would happen if they spoke Spanish during your class?
Grab the FREE toolkit for creating a welcoming and affirming environment.
Follow me on instagram: @empower_edteacher
Follow me on TikTok: @empower_ed
So excited to share my very first children’s book! Written with love for my two little loves and excited to share with the rest of you. Perfect for ages 0-4.
